Direct answer

How do I set a free shipping threshold that does not lose money?

Look at your order values and find where most orders fall. Set the threshold a little above a common order value, at a point a customer can reach by adding one typical item. Then check the order that only just reaches it: after product cost, packaging, payment fees and the shipping you now pay, its contribution should be at least what a typical order earned when the customer paid for shipping. If it is not, raise the threshold or keep paid shipping for costly zones.

What a threshold is supposed to do

A free shipping threshold moves shipping from the customer to you on every order above a set value. It pays off when enough customers add an item to reach it, so the extra product contribution covers the shipping you absorb. It costs you on orders that were already above the threshold, because those customers would have paid for shipping and no longer do.

Read your order values, not just the average

Export recent orders from Shopify and group them by order value in simple bands. An average order value can be pulled up by a few large orders and hides where most customers actually stop. Look for the band where orders cluster and note what one typical extra item costs.

A threshold just above that cluster, reachable by adding one item, gives many customers a realistic reason to add something. A threshold far above it rarely changes behaviour. A threshold below it mostly gives shipping away.

Test the order that only just qualifies

Fictional numbers in any currency, not merchant results. Product cost is 40 percent of item value, packaging is 20 per order, payment fees are 2 percent, and shipping costs you 80 per order. Today customers pay a flat 60 for shipping.

Paid shipping order compared with orders at two thresholds

Typical order today, 700 of products plus 60 shipping paid by the customer: revenue 760, product cost 280, shipping 80, packaging 20, fee about 15. Contribution about 365.

Threshold at 1,000, order of exactly 1,000 with free shipping: product cost 400, shipping 90 for the heavier parcel, packaging 20, fee 20. Contribution 470, above 365, so the threshold holds up.

Threshold at 500, order of exactly 500 with free shipping: product cost 200, shipping 80, packaging 20, fee 10. Contribution 190, well below 365, so this threshold gives margin away.

Also count the cost on orders already above the threshold: each one loses the 60 the customer used to pay.

Set it by zone if shipping costs differ

Shipping to a distant zone or a remote area can cost much more than local delivery. In Shopify you can set rates per shipping zone, so a single store wide threshold is not required. Keep the threshold where the arithmetic works, and use a higher threshold or a paid rate for zones where it does not.

Shopify supports free shipping in two ways: a shipping rate that applies above an order value, and a free shipping discount with a minimum purchase amount. With the discount, Shopify notes that when a combinable discount lowers the price first, the lower price is what counts toward the minimum. Check how your other offers combine with it.

COD orders need their own check

If you sell cash on delivery, an order that is refused or returned costs shipping both ways and earns nothing. Free shipping makes that loss larger because you no longer collect a shipping charge on delivered orders to offset it. If your COD return rate is high, consider a higher threshold for COD, or free shipping on prepaid orders only. The COD and RTO guide covers the calculation.

Review it after a few weeks

Compare a few weeks after the change with a similar period before it: share of orders at or above the threshold, contribution per order, total contribution and returns. Watch for small add on items that are returned, which can undo the gain.

Munafa calculates true Shopify profit after product cost, shipping, packaging, payment fees, COD fees and RTO losses, so you can compare contribution per order before and after a threshold change. It shows the result; it does not set the threshold for you.

Sources and definitions

Related Shopify resources

Frequently asked questions

Should my free shipping threshold be above my average order value?

Usually a little above where most orders cluster, so a customer can reach it by adding one typical item. Use the spread of your order values rather than the average alone, which a few large orders can distort.

Is a free shipping discount the same as a free shipping rate in Shopify?

No. A rate with an order value condition is part of your shipping settings, while a free shipping discount is set up under discounts and can have a minimum purchase amount and combination rules. Both give free shipping; they interact with other offers differently.

Does free shipping make sense for COD orders?

Only if the arithmetic holds after refused and returned orders. Those orders cost shipping both ways and earn nothing, so stores with high COD returns often set a higher threshold for COD or limit free shipping to prepaid orders.

Can Munafa set my free shipping threshold?

No. Munafa reports true profit and contribution per order from your orders and cost settings, which shows whether a threshold is working. Choosing the threshold is your decision.

Next step

Try Munafa on your own store

Munafa calculates true Shopify profit after COGS, shipping, packaging, payment fees, COD fees, and RTO losses.

One email when something new ships. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.