Direct answer

How much can I discount a product on Shopify before I lose money?

Work out the contribution on one order at full price: the price the customer pays, minus product cost, shipping, packaging, payment fees and an allowance for returns. That contribution is the most a discount can take before the order loses money, so the break-even discount is roughly contribution divided by price. To keep the same total profit, the discount also has to raise orders: you need the original contribution divided by the discounted contribution, times your normal number of orders.

Start from contribution, not markup

Markup compares price with product cost only. Contribution is what an order leaves after every cost that comes with it: product cost, outbound shipping you pay, packaging, payment or COD fees, and an allowance for returns or undelivered COD orders. A discount reduces the price but leaves most of those costs exactly where they were, so it comes out of contribution in full.

Use the cost per item you record in Shopify for product cost, and your real carrier and packaging costs rather than the shipping you charge. The guide on Shopify profit per order shows the full order level calculation.

The break-even discount

If an order earns contribution C at a price P, a discount equal to C takes the order to zero. As a percentage, the break-even discount is about C divided by P. It is slightly higher in practice because payment fees usually fall a little when the customer pays less. Any discount above this loses money on every order, however many extra orders it brings.

Calculate it per product or per typical order, not for the store as a whole. A store wide average hides the low contribution items that a sitewide discount pushes into a loss.

The extra orders a discount has to create

Below break-even, each discounted order still earns something, just less. To keep total profit level, the discount has to bring enough extra orders to make up the gap. The multiplier is the full price contribution divided by the discounted contribution. If an order earned 450 and earns 254 after the discount, you need about 1.77 times as many orders, or 77 percent more, just to stand still.

This is why small looking discounts on low contribution products are expensive. The closer the discount gets to break-even, the faster the required lift grows.

Worked example

Fictional numbers in any currency, not merchant results.

One product at full price, 10 percent off and 20 percent off

Full price 1,000. Product cost 400, shipping 80, packaging 20, payment fee at 2 percent 20, returns allowance 30. Contribution 450, or 45 percent of price.

Break-even discount: about 45 percent, a little more because the payment fee falls with the price.

10 percent off: price 900, fee 18, contribution 352. Orders needed to match full price profit: 450 divided by 352, about 1.28 times, or 28 percent more.

20 percent off: price 800, fee 16, contribution 254. Orders needed: 450 divided by 254, about 1.77 times, or 77 percent more.

Decision: the 20 percent offer only makes sense if you have good reason to expect close to double the orders, or if it serves another goal such as clearing overstock.

Shopify settings that change the arithmetic

  • Combined discounts: Shopify lets you choose whether a discount can combine with product, order and shipping discounts. Two offers that each look safe can stack past break-even. Check the combination settings on every active discount.
  • Free shipping discounts: these add your shipping cost to the discount. Shopify also notes that when a combinable discount lowers the price first, the lower price is what counts toward a free shipping minimum.
  • Order level discounts: an amount off the whole order is spread across its items, so check the contribution of the lowest margin item in a typical basket.
  • Payment method: COD orders that are refused or returned carry shipping both ways. If a discount attracts more COD orders, include that cost in the returns allowance.

Check the result after the promotion

Compare contribution, not revenue, for the discount period against a similar period without it: number of orders, contribution per order, returns and undelivered COD orders, and whether sales simply moved forward from the weeks after. A promotion that raised revenue and lowered total contribution was not a success.

Munafa calculates true Shopify profit after product cost, shipping, packaging, payment fees, COD fees and RTO losses, so you can see contribution per order before and after a discount. It reports what happened; it does not choose a discount or predict how many extra orders an offer will bring.

Sources and definitions

Related Shopify resources

Frequently asked questions

Is a 20 percent discount safe if my margin is 50 percent?

Not necessarily. If the 50 percent is markup over product cost, shipping, packaging, fees and returns can leave a much smaller contribution. Calculate contribution per order first; the discount has to stay below it, and every point closer to it needs more extra orders.

Should I offer a discount or free shipping?

Compare what each costs per order. Free shipping costs your real shipping rate on every qualifying order, while a percentage discount costs more on expensive items. The guide on setting a free shipping threshold shows how to test the order at the threshold.

Do discounts change Shopify payment fees?

Payment fees are usually charged on the amount the customer pays, so a discount often lowers the fee slightly. Check the fee terms of your own payment provider and use them in the calculation.

Can Munafa tell me what discount to run?

No. Munafa shows true profit and contribution from your orders and cost settings, which tells you how much room a product has and how a past promotion performed. Choosing and forecasting an offer is still your decision.

Next step

Try Munafa on your own store

Munafa calculates true Shopify profit after COGS, shipping, packaging, payment fees, COD fees, and RTO losses.

One email when something new ships. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.